| Place | Name | Affiliation | Time |
| 1 | Cody Morrison | Ohio Wesleyan | 4:41.65 |
| 2 | Jacoby Michael | Otterbein College | 4:44.87 |
| 3 | Matt Dixon | Otterbein College | 4:44.94 |
| 4 | Peter MacLeod | Ohio Wesleyan | 4:49.44 |
| 5 | Michael Cynkar | The College of Wooster | 4:51.96 |
| 6 | Mike Shirar | Denison University | 4:52.45 |
| 7 | Scott Williams | Ohio Wesleyan | 4:53.25 |
| 8 | Matt Smith | Allegheny College | 4:54.59 |
| 9 | Chris Bennett | Denison University | 4:55.31 |
| 10 | Dan Rafferty | Denison University | 4:55.91 |
| DNS | Clinton Kugler | Kenyon College | |
| DNS | Jamie Drab | Allegheny College |